Vol. I · Issue 01 · The Quarterly of Plastic

Advertiser Disclosure →

SIDE A

A

Apple / Goldman Sachs · Mastercard

Apple Card

VS.

×

SIDE B

B

Citi · Mastercard

Citi Double Cash Card


FILING

Head-to-Head · Plastic Quarterly

The Apple Card and Citi Double Cash represent two fundamentally different reward philosophies. The Apple Card demands you live in Apple's ecosystem to maximize returns, offering up to 3% cash back on select categories but only 1% on most purchases. The Citi Double Cash takes a simpler approach: a flat 2% back on everything, with no category hunting required. The Apple Card edges out slightly on pure rewards if you're a heavy Apple Pay user and shop at bonus merchants, but the Citi Double Cash wins on simplicity and consistency. Both charge no annual fee and target the same credit score range. Your choice depends on whether you value category optimization or predictable, straightforward rewards.

THE VERDICT

Our ruling.

Choose the Citi Double Cash Card for most people. It delivers a superior baseline 2% back on every purchase without requiring you to remember bonus categories or use Apple Pay, making it genuinely useful for broader spending patterns. The Apple Card only wins if you're deeply embedded in Apple's ecosystem and frequent its bonus merchants regularly.

CHOOSE A

Side A is for you if

  • 01You use Apple Pay for the majority of your purchases and want 2% back automatically on those transactions
  • 02You spend significantly at Apple's bonus merchants (Nike, Uber, Walgreens) and the App Store, where 3% cash back adds up quickly
  • 03You want tight spending integration with your iPhone and use the Wallet app's budgeting tools actively
  • 04You prefer receiving rewards as Daily Cash that hits your account immediately rather than waiting for statement credits

CHOOSE B

Side B is for you if

  • 01You want the same 2% cash back on every single purchase with no categories to track or optimize
  • 02You plan to transfer a balance and value the 0% intro APR on balance transfers for 18 months
  • 03You're not a heavy Apple ecosystem user and want a card that works consistently everywhere Mastercard is accepted
  • 04You prefer simplicity and predictability over chasing bonus categories that may not align with your actual spending

THE LEDGER

Side by side.

ISSUER
Apple / Goldman Sachs
Citi
NETWORK
Mastercard
Mastercard
ANNUAL FEE
$0
$0
APR RANGE
19.24% – 29.49%
18.24% – 28.24%
INTRO APR (PURCHASES)
None
None
INTRO APR (BALANCE TRANSFERS)
None
0% for 18 months
REWARDS TYPE
cashback
cashback
REWARDS RATE
1% cash back on physical card purchases
2% cash back (1% on purchase, 1% on payment)
SIGN-UP BONUS
None
None
BONUS VALUE
MIN. CREDIT SCORE
670+
670+
FOREIGN TRANSACTION FEE
None
Yes (3%)

A HIGHLIGHTS

Apple Card

  • Daily Cash paid daily to Apple Cash or Savings account
  • 3% back at Apple and select merchants
  • 2% back on all Apple Pay purchases
  • No fees — no annual, late, international, or over-limit fees
  • Built-in budgeting tools and spending summaries in the Wallet app

B HIGHLIGHTS

Citi Double Cash Card

  • Flat 2% cash back on everything — no categories to track
  • 0% intro APR on balance transfers for 18 months
  • No annual fee
  • Citi Entertainment access for event presales
  • Earn ThankYou Points transferable to airline partners

QUESTIONS · ANSWERS

Frequently filed.

No. The Apple Card pays 1% on physical card purchases, 2% on Apple Pay, and 3% only at Apple and select merchants. Most people will earn 1-2% on typical spending. The Citi Double Cash guarantees 2% everywhere with no conditions attached.