Vol. I · Issue 01 · The Quarterly of Plastic

Advertiser Disclosure →

SIDE A

A

Bank of America · Visa

Bank of America Premium Rewards Credit Card

VS.

×

SIDE B

B

Citi · Mastercard

Citi Premier Card


FILING

Head-to-Head · Plastic Quarterly

Both cards charge $95 annually and offer identical 60,000-point signup bonuses, but they reward different spending patterns. Bank of America's Premium Rewards focuses on travel and dining with 2x points in those categories, plus valuable travel credits and integration with its Preferred Rewards program. Citi Premier spreads its 3x bonus across five categories—restaurants, supermarkets, gas, air travel, and hotels—making it more versatile for everyday spending. The real difference emerges in how you travel and eat. If you're a frequent diner or prioritize premium travel perks, Bank of America wins. If you fill up at gas stations, buy groceries, and want broader category coverage, Citi delivers better value. Neither card is ideal for general spenders who don't max these categories.

THE VERDICT

Our ruling.

Choose Bank of America Premium Rewards if travel is your priority and you dine out regularly. Choose Citi Premier if you want flexibility across everyday categories like groceries and gas. For most travelers, Bank of America edges ahead due to its superior travel credits and airline perks, but Citi's wider bonus categories make it better for cost-conscious households.

CHOOSE A

Side A is for you if

  • 01You fly regularly and value the $100 airline incidental credit plus Global Entry/TSA PreCheck reimbursement—these benefits alone nearly cover the annual fee
  • 02You dine out at least $300+ monthly and want 2x points consistently without category limits
  • 03You're a Bank of America customer eligible for Preferred Rewards, which adds 25-75% point multipliers on top of existing rewards
  • 04You prioritize premium travel protection and don't need rewards on grocery or gas purchases

CHOOSE B

Side B is for you if

  • 01You spend regularly at supermarkets and gas stations—3x points here versus 1.5x on Bank of America creates meaningful value
  • 02You prefer a single versatile card rather than maximizing specific categories; five bonus categories provide more flexibility
  • 03You value hotel stays with the $100 annual hotel savings benefit and want 3x points on hotel bookings
  • 04You're not a frequent flyer but appreciate the ability to transfer points to 15+ airline partners for eventual redemption

THE LEDGER

Side by side.

ISSUER
Bank of America
Citi
NETWORK
Visa
Mastercard
ANNUAL FEE
$95
$95
APR RANGE
19.24% – 29.24%
21.24% – 29.24%
INTRO APR (PURCHASES)
None
None
INTRO APR (BALANCE TRANSFERS)
None
None
REWARDS TYPE
points
points
REWARDS RATE
1.5 points per dollar on all purchases
1x ThankYou points on all purchases
SIGN-UP BONUS
60,000 points
60,000 points
BONUS VALUE
$600
$600
MIN. CREDIT SCORE
700+
700+
FOREIGN TRANSACTION FEE
None
None

A HIGHLIGHTS

Bank of America Premium Rewards Credit Card

  • 2 points per dollar on travel and dining
  • Up to $100 airline incidental statement credit
  • Up to $100 Global Entry or TSA PreCheck credit
  • Preferred Rewards members earn 25-75% more points
  • No foreign transaction fees

B HIGHLIGHTS

Citi Premier Card

  • 3x points on restaurants, supermarkets, gas, air travel, and hotels
  • Transfer ThankYou Points to 15+ airline partners
  • No foreign transaction fees
  • $100 annual hotel savings benefit
  • Citi Entertainment access

QUESTIONS · ANSWERS

Frequently filed.

Bank of America wins with 1.5x points on all purchases versus Citi's 1x. If you don't consistently hit bonus categories, Bank of America's baseline rewards are 50% stronger. This matters if you spend outside travel, dining, groceries, and gas.