Vol. I · Issue 01 · The Quarterly of Plastic

Advertiser Disclosure →

SIDE A

A

Citi · Mastercard

Citi Premier Card

VS.

×

SIDE B

B

Chase · Visa

Chase Sapphire Preferred Card


FILING

Head-to-Head · Plastic Quarterly

The Citi Premier and Chase Sapphire Preferred are nearly identical premium travel cards with matching $95 annual fees and 60,000-point signup bonuses. The key difference lies in category breadth versus redemption flexibility. Citi Premier spreads 3x points across five categories including supermarkets and gas stations, making it better for everyday spending. Chase Sapphire Preferred concentrates rewards on travel and dining but offers superior point valuation through its travel portal (25% bonus) and slightly better insurance protections. Both require 700+ credit scores and waive foreign transaction fees. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize diverse earning categories or maximum redemption value.

THE VERDICT

Our ruling.

Chase Sapphire Preferred wins for most travelers. Its 5x points on Chase Travel purchases, combined with the 25% redemption bonus, creates better overall value despite fewer bonus categories. Citi Premier only makes sense if you heavily use supermarkets and gas stations.

CHOOSE A

Side A is for you if

  • 01You spend significantly at supermarkets and gas stations—categories Sapphire doesn't cover—making Citi's 3x points valuable for weekly groceries and fuel
  • 02You prioritize transfer partners and want airline-focused rewards without the travel portal dependency
  • 03You value the $100 annual hotel savings benefit and don't rely on the Chase Travel portal for bookings
  • 04You want the broadest earning potential across everyday categories rather than concentrated travel rewards

CHOOSE B

Side B is for you if

  • 01You book travel through Chase's portal regularly—the 5x points and 25% redemption bonus add up to 6.25 effective points per dollar
  • 02You dine out frequently and want strong dining rewards (3x) combined with premium travel protections like trip cancellation insurance
  • 03You use streaming services and shop online groceries—Sapphire's niche categories align better with modern spending
  • 04You maximize credit card value through strategic point transfers to premium airline partners where Sapphire's larger point pool matters

THE LEDGER

Side by side.

ISSUER
Citi
Chase
NETWORK
Mastercard
Visa
ANNUAL FEE
$95
$95
APR RANGE
21.24% – 29.24%
21.49% – 28.49%
INTRO APR (PURCHASES)
None
None
INTRO APR (BALANCE TRANSFERS)
None
None
REWARDS TYPE
points
points
REWARDS RATE
1x ThankYou points on all purchases
1x points on all purchases
SIGN-UP BONUS
60,000 points
60,000 points
BONUS VALUE
$600
$750
MIN. CREDIT SCORE
700+
700+
FOREIGN TRANSACTION FEE
None
None

A HIGHLIGHTS

Citi Premier Card

  • 3x points on restaurants, supermarkets, gas, air travel, and hotels
  • Transfer ThankYou Points to 15+ airline partners
  • No foreign transaction fees
  • $100 annual hotel savings benefit
  • Citi Entertainment access

B HIGHLIGHTS

Chase Sapphire Preferred Card

  • Points worth 25% more when redeemed through Chase Travel
  • Transfer points to 14+ airline and hotel partners
  • $50 annual Chase Travel hotel credit
  • No foreign transaction fees
  • Trip cancellation and interruption insurance

QUESTIONS · ANSWERS

Frequently filed.

Both earn 3x points on dining. However, Chase Sapphire Preferred's points are worth 25% more when redeemed through Chase Travel, making dining effectively 3.75x value. Citi Premier offers straight 3x with no redemption bonus.